Search Appropriateness Statement Package
Treatments
< 1 min read
The following section covers a number of commonly used treatment and therapeutic practices. These include substance use screening and evaluation, mental health screening and evaluation, cognitive-behavioral therapy, alcohol and drug education, and drug treatment (in-patient, out-patient). Also provided are implementation recommendations on how organizations can prepare themselves to make changes to their policies on treatment practices. Additionally, this section contains practice guidelines which include the results of the empirical evidence analysis.
The following table shows a summary of the results from the evidence analysis. The practices is categorized according to four levels: appropriate, promising, inconclusive, and not evidence-based depending on the amount and type of research available (see Introduction Table 2 for definitions). Also included are the perceptions of individuals working in supervision agencies and individuals that have experience with the justice system to illustrate different views about the contacts. The following table summarizes the evidence level, the probation staff perceptions, and JSI perceptions of the practices in this section.
Table 5
Levels of Support for Treatment Practices
Practice
Research Support
Field Support: Low Risk
Field Support: Med/High Risk
Probation
JSI
Probation
JSI
Substance Use Evaluation
Mental Health Evaluation
Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy
Alcohol & Drug Use Education
In- or Out-Patient Treatment
Evidence-Based*
Evidence-Based*
Evidence-Based
Not Evidence-Based
Evidence-Based
Moderate
Moderate
Moderate
Moderate
Moderate
Moderate
Moderate
Moderate
Moderate
Moderate
Wide
Wide
Wide
Moderate
Wide
Moderate
Moderate
Moderate
Moderate
Moderate
* = Evidence-based with qualifications